Fresh & Homemade

Every clean, organic pick we'd buy in this aisle — compare by size, price, and organic certification before you buy.

Know a better option? Tell us.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links are affiliate links — if you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Organic plain whole-milk Greek yogurt

Organic plain whole-milk Greek yogurt

The base for homemade cream cheese — strain it overnight and you're done. Full-fat, live cultures, no thickeners or added starch.

BrandSizeOrganic
365 by Whole Foods Market 32 oz Yes Shop →
Stonyfield 30 oz Yes Shop →
Maple Hill Creamery 16 oz Yes Shop →
Organic unbleached cheesecloth

Organic unbleached cheesecloth

GOTS-certified cotton, no bleach or synthetic finishes. Drapes over a strainer to drain yogurt into cream cheese. Reusable — rinse, boil, repeat.

BrandSizeOrganic
Country Trading Co. 23x23 in (2-pack) Yes Shop →
Country Trading Co. 18 sq ft Yes Shop →
Olicity 36x36 in (9 sq ft) Yes Shop →